Starting Fresh or Building On? A Comparison of Redesign Strategies

Redesigning a user interface or user experience (UI/UX) can be a challenging task, as it involves not only updating the look and feel of a product or service but also ensuring that it meets the needs and expectations of the users. There are different approaches to redesigning a UI/UX, each with its own advantages and disadvantages. In this blog post, we will explore some of the key considerations and approaches to redesigning a UI/UX, including starting from scratch, building on the existing design, and redesigning with inheritance. We will also discuss the importance of considering past mistakes and learning from them in order to improve the overall user experience. By understanding the different approaches and considerations, designers can make informed decisions and create a redesign that effectively addresses the needs of the users while also meeting the goals of the project.

When it comes to redesigning a user interface or user experience, designers have two main options: starting from scratch or building on the existing design. Each approach has its own advantages and disadvantages, and it's important to consider the specific goals of the redesign and the constraints of the project when making a decision.

Starting from scratch:

‍Advantages:‍

• A clean slate allows for greater creativity and flexibility in the design process. Designers can explore new ideas, layouts, and interactions without being constrained by the previous design.
• Starting fresh can help to avoid any constraints or limitations imposed by the previous design. This can be especially beneficial if the previous design had significant usability or accessibility issues that cannot be easily resolved.
• It can be an opportunity to re-define the brand and visual identity for the product or service.

‍Disadvantages:

• ‍‍It can be time-consuming and costly to start from scratch, as all research and analysis must be done from scratch. This can include user research, competitive analysis, and data analysis.
• It can be difficult to maintain consistency with the previous design, which can make the transition for existing users more difficult.
• It can be harder to justify the investment and resources needed for a complete redesign to the stakeholders.

Building on the existing design:

Advantages:

• ‍‍By building on the existing design, designers can take advantage of what worked well in the previous design. This can include elements that users were familiar with and enjoyed using, which can help to minimize disruption to the user experience.
• This approach can be more cost-effective and efficient, as some research and analysis can be reused. This can include user research data and design metrics, which can help to inform the redesign process.
• It can be an opportunity to improve the design incrementally and iteratively, which can be less risky and more cost-effective than a complete redesign.

Disadvantages:

• The previous design may have fundamental issues that cannot be easily resolved by building on top of it. This can include poor usability, accessibility, or scalability issues that may require a more significant redesign to address.
• It can be harder to make significant changes to the design without disrupting the existing user experience. This can make it difficult to achieve the desired goals of the redesign, such as improving usability or increasing engagement.

Another approach to redesigning a user interface or user experience is by using the concept of inheritance. Inheritance in design refers to the ability to reuse and build upon existing design patterns, components, or modules. This approach can be especially useful when redesigning a large, complex system with many different components.

Advantages of redesigning with inheritance:

• ‍Efficiency: By reusing existing design patterns, components, or modules, designers can save time and resources that would otherwise be spent on creating new ones from scratch.
• Consistency: By reusing existing design patterns, designers can ensure consistency across the design, which can improve the overall user experience and make it easier for users to understand and navigate the system.
• Flexibility: By building upon existing design patterns, designers can create new variations that can be adapted to different contexts, while still maintaining consistency.
• Scalability: By creating a library of reusable design patterns, designers can easily scale the design as new features or functionality are added to the system.

Disadvantages of redesigning with inheritance:

• Limited creativity: By reusing existing design patterns, designers may be limited in their ability to explore new ideas or create unique designs.
• Difficulty in change: If the previous design patterns were not well-designed or were not adequate for the new requirements, it can be difficult to change them without affecting the consistency and usability.
• Upkeep: In order to maintain consistency and scalability, designers must ensure that the library of design patterns is kept up-to-date and relevant.

When redesigning with inheritance, it's important to strike a balance between reusing existing design patterns and exploring new ideas. By carefully selecting which design patterns to reuse and which to create from scratch, designers can create a design that is efficient, consistent, and user-friendly. Additionally, it's important to keep in mind that the redesign process is an iterative process, and that adjustments and improvements can continue to be made even after the redesign is launched. By continuously monitoring and evaluating the redesign, designers can identify and address any new issues that may arise and continue to improve the overall user experience.

In conclusion, redesigning a user interface or user experience requires careful consideration of the goals of the redesign, the constraints of the project, and the needs of the users. Different approaches, such as starting from scratch, building on the existing design, and redesigning with inheritance, each have their own advantages and disadvantages. By understanding the different approaches and considerations, designers can make informed decisions and create a redesign that effectively addresses the needs of the users while also meeting the goals of the project. Additionally, it is important to consider past mistakes, and to continuously monitor and evaluate the redesign to make adjustments and improvements as needed. With these strategies in mind, designers can create a redesign that improves the overall user experience and achieves the goals of the project.

‍